Ai Concept

Beyond Bad Advice: Three Other Reasons for Concern When Clients Use AI During a Divorce

Most people are aware of the dangers of hallucinations and false information when using generative artificial intelligence (AI). These issues are particularly perilous when clients use AI to ask about family law, a field in which good advice is often extremely case-specific. But receiving bad advice isn’t the only pitfall when clients use AI in connection with a divorce—here are three other things to consider before asking AI.

Losing Privilege and Privacy

When a client communicates with an attorney, those communications are generally protected by the attorney-client privilege. Attorneys’ work product created on behalf of a client is similarly privileged. In litigation, opposing parties cannot discover privileged information and documents.

These privileges are limited to communications with attorneys and work completed by attorneys. When a client asks questions on an AI platform about their case, the information the client provides may be discoverable by the opposing party.

Additionally, information provided to certain AI platforms could become available to other users. Most free-to-use AI platforms are “open” or “public” systems, meaning that both inputs and outputs are used as part of the ongoing training of AI models. Any questions or context given to an “open” AI system could reappear in its answers to other users’ questions. Before inputting information about your situation into an open or public AI platform, it’s important to ask yourself whether you would be comfortable with other users of that platform seeing that information.

Driving Up Attorney’s Fee

Attorneys have an ethical obligation to provide competent representation. That is not an obligation that can be outsourced to AI. When an attorney uses AI tools as an aid, that attorney has a responsibility to verify any work completed by an AI system, as well as to manage any risks associated with AI use.

An attorney’s use of AI tools—through a closed system that avoids loss of privacy—aids in representing a client without exposure to additional risks. On the other hand, when clients use AI to find information and make suggestions to attorneys, the result is likely to be an increase in fees with little to no increase in value: When a client raises suggestions generated by AI, attorneys have to independently verify whether those suggestions are applicable, weigh them against the existing strategy, and explain the ramifications to the client. All of that takes up time and increases fees. And, given the nuances of divorce cases and the courts that manage them, it is more likely than not that AI-generated suggestions fail to account for client’s particular circumstances, especially if an experienced family law attorney has already chosen against the paths suggested. In that case, fees are incurred for no gain, that is, to explore and explain myriad non-viable suggestions.

Compromising Communication

All of the above is not to say that clients should stay silent. In a divorce, a client is the foremost expert on their own life. It is that expertise, unfiltered by AI, that family law attorneys need to be able to draw from.

This principle extends beyond correspondence with attorneys. It is important to consider the consequences of sending AI-produced correspondence when communicating with other parties who know you well or who may be sensitive to AI usage. For example, if an opposing party or judge finds AI-“polished” communication disingenuous or jarring, the positives of that “polish” may be outweighed by the negative associations that AI usage can carry.

In the end, knowing the risks of AI usage is key, no matter where you are in your divorce action. If you aren’t sure, ask your attorney before starting a prompt.

 

Categorized: Artificial Intelligence, Divorce

Tagged In: , ,

About the Authors

Katelyn Lee Listing
Stay Connected
LinkedIn

Associate

Katelyn Lee

Katelyn Lee focuses her practice on family law, representing clients in matters involving divorce, child custody, parenting arrangements, and other family-related legal issues. She brings to her practice a strong foundation in legal research, writing, and analysis developed through judicial clerkships and clinical experience.

Stay Connected
LinkedIn

More Posts by Author ›

About the Authors

Katelyn Lee Listing
Stay Connected
LinkedIn

Associate

Katelyn Lee

Katelyn Lee focuses her practice on family law, representing clients in matters involving divorce, child custody, parenting arrangements, and other family-related legal issues. She brings to her practice a strong foundation in legal research, writing, and analysis developed through judicial clerkships and clinical experience.

Stay Connected
LinkedIn

More Posts by Author ›

Stay Connected

Subscribe to Blog

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.