Skip Navigation
Lawyer is reading contract and business client is typing on laptop.

Client Alert: Federal Court Blocks New FLSA Regulations

On November 22, Judge Mazzant of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas entered a nationwide injunction blocking the Department of Labor’s updated regulations under the Fair Labor Standards Act.

Last Summer, the Department of Labor announced sweeping changes to the regulations governing the executive, administrative and professional exemptions from overtime pay under the FLSA (the so-called “EAP exemptions”). In particular, the announced regulations increased the salary level to qualify for the EAP exemptions from $455 per week to $913 per week and also provided that the salary level would update automatically every three years based on Bureau of Labor Statistics data. The new regulations, which the Department of Labor estimated would expand overtime eligibility to more than 4 million additional workers, were set to take effect on December 1.

Seeking to block the new regulations, the State of Nevada and several other states (not including Massachusetts) filed a lawsuit in federal court in Texas. The States argued that the new regulations exceeded the Department of Labor’s authority.

In a 20-page decision, the Court agreed with the States. The Court reasoned that the FLSA expressly provided an exemption from overtime for those employed in a “bona fide executive, administrative or professional capacity,” but made no provision for a particular salary level that would be required. Thus, according to the Court, Congress intended the EAP exemptions to focus on the duties an employee performed to assess whether the individual should be exempt from overtime; though the terms “executive,” “administrative,” and “professional” were not defined in the statute, the Court reviewed dictionary definitions of those terms from the 1930s (when the FLSA was enacted) to understand their meanings. The Court then found that the Department of Labor’s new regulations would create a “de facto salary-only test,” as employees who were not earning at least $913 per week would not qualify as exempt regardless of the work they performed, and therefore exceeded the Department of Labor’s authority to interpret and implement the statute. (The Court disclaimed any intention of questioning the legality of the current salary level test, though its reasoning in rejecting the new regulations suggests that any salary level set by regulation would be unlawful.) Further, the Court decided that its decision blocking the new regulations should apply nationwide, to avoid the confusion of different EAP exemption tests applying in different areas of the country.

As a result of this decision, employers that have been scrambling for months to analyze their current workforce and deciding how to address the Department of Labor’s new rules are left in an uncertain state. The Department of Labor has the right to appeal the Court’s decision, though with an upcoming change in Presidential administrations it is unclear whether an appeal, if filed, would be pursued to its conclusion (and even if so, whether an appeal would be successful). In the meantime, employers now must grapple with issues of how to manage their workforce going forward, especially with respect to those employees who had been told that their salaries would be increasing on December 1 to account for the new regulations.

For more information, please contact Robert Young, the author of this alert, David Felper, Practice Area Leader for the firm’s Labor & Employment and Higher Education Practice Areas or your attorney at Bowditch & Dewey LLP.

About the Authors

Robert Young
Stay Connected
LinkedIn

Partner

Robert G. Young

Bob Young, editor of the At the Bar with Bowditch blog, is an experienced advisor and trial lawyer, helping clients navigate complex employment and  labor issues and defending employers facing claims in the state and federal courts of Massachusetts and before administrative agencies. Bob regularly represents businesses, municipalities, educational institutions and non-profit organizations of all sizes, as well as high-level executives, in high-exposure claims and disputes involving discrimination and retaliation, non-competition, trade secrets, wage-and-hour and other complex, constantly evolving employment-related issues.

Stay Connected
LinkedIn

More Posts by Author ›

David M Felper.
Stay Connected
LinkedIn

Of Counsel

David M. Felper

David Felper is a senior labor and employment lawyer, focusing his practice on advising colleges and universities, nonprofits and social service agencies, primarily in central Massachusetts. David also represents employers in the manufacturing sector along with other traditional businesses. “My clients vary in size, ranging from a few employees to several thousand. Regardless of their size or type, I strive to be highly responsive.”

Stay Connected
LinkedIn

More Posts by Author ›

About the Authors

Robert Young
Stay Connected
LinkedIn

Partner

Robert G. Young

Bob Young, editor of the At the Bar with Bowditch blog, is an experienced advisor and trial lawyer, helping clients navigate complex employment and  labor issues and defending employers facing claims in the state and federal courts of Massachusetts and before administrative agencies. Bob regularly represents businesses, municipalities, educational institutions and non-profit organizations of all sizes, as well as high-level executives, in high-exposure claims and disputes involving discrimination and retaliation, non-competition, trade secrets, wage-and-hour and other complex, constantly evolving employment-related issues.

Stay Connected
LinkedIn

More Posts by Author ›

David M Felper.
Stay Connected
LinkedIn

Of Counsel

David M. Felper

David Felper is a senior labor and employment lawyer, focusing his practice on advising colleges and universities, nonprofits and social service agencies, primarily in central Massachusetts. David also represents employers in the manufacturing sector along with other traditional businesses. “My clients vary in size, ranging from a few employees to several thousand. Regardless of their size or type, I strive to be highly responsive.”

Stay Connected
LinkedIn

More Posts by Author ›

View All People ›

    To get in touch, please call us at 508-791-3511 or fill out the form below. Fields in orange are required.

    Stay Current

    Subscribe to Bowditch’s updates, alerts and programs.

    Subscribe to All

     


    You can also follow our Bowditch Blogs. Please subscribe for new post notifications directly on the blogs. They are easily accessible in the main navigation under the Insights+News dropdown.

    An email confirmation will be sent upon submitting this form.